DAYTON, OHIO
The good stuff, shipped nationwide ● Free shipping on orders $75+
Est. 2026
Meet the Team

Brian Kinnison
Owner
A long time collector and avid toy enthusiast turned toy shop owner with two long time friends!

Chaddwic Shay
Owner
Avid sports enthusiast turned shop owner, with brother and good friend.

Jesse Shay
Owner
Long time business owner and collector. Owner and operator of your local Hanks restaurant turned dual owner.

Collin Fegel
Social Media and Event Manager
Avid collector/competitor and new business partner of Shay Toys!

Tyler Whaley
Sports Specialist
Avid Sports fan and enthusiast and new partner at Shay Toys!
Our passionate team is here to help you discover great toys, trading cards, and collectibles. Whether you're looking for a specific item, need help with your collection, or want to sell your stuff, we're happy to help.
Want to speak with our team?
[Contact Us]
.png)